The Comeback Mascara

$30.24

Size

CleanHub

Your purchase removes 1 lb of plastic waste from the environment.

Powered by CleanHub
info icon CleanHub uses technology to keep plastic out of the sea by collecting, tracking and recovering it with full transparency.

Details

Introducing "The Comeback" Mascara

What It Is:

Prepare for the ultimate lash transformation with "The Comeback" mascara. This revolutionary formula is designed to deliver unparalleled length, volume, and definition to your lashes. Each swipe of the unique faceted brush head coats every lash from root to tip, ensuring maximum lift, gloss, and precision.

What’s In It:

  • Tea Extract: Known for its antioxidant properties, tea extract helps protect your lashes from environmental damage, keeping them looking fresh and healthy.
  • Acai Oil: Packed with essential fatty acids and vitamins, acai oil nourishes and revitalizes your lashes, promoting natural volume and length.
  • Vitamin C: This powerful antioxidant boosts lash health by combating free radicals and supporting collagen production, contributing to stronger, more resilient lashes.

Why We Love It:

We love "The Comeback" Mascara for its dual-purpose benefits: it not only amplifies the beauty of your lashes but also cares for them deeply. The warm water-removable formula ensures easy removal without the need for harsh chemicals or excessive rubbing, preserving the health of your lashes. Enriched with powerful natural ingredients, this mascara provides antioxidant and anti-aging benefits, making it a true beauty essential.

Please note this item is final sale.

How to Use It

To apply, place the wand at the base of your upper lashes and brush in an upwards motion, ensuring to coat each lash.

Pro Tip: Wait a few seconds before applying a second coat for maximized results.

Shade Description

Demi-Matte Black

Ingredients

◊Water/Aqua, Acrylates/Ethylhexyl Acrylate Copolymer, Glyceryl Stearate, ◊Oryza Sativa (Rice) Bran Wax, ◊Glycerin, Tribehenin, Stearic Acid, Synthetic Wax, Palmitic Acid, Dimer Dilinoleyl Dimer Dilinoleate, ◊Jojoba Esters, ◊Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Wax, ◊Rhus Succedanea (Japanese) Fruit Wax, ◊Camellia Sinensis (Green Tea) Leaf Extract, Hydroxyethylcellulose, Caprylyl Glycol, ◊Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Oil, Sodium Hydroxide, Ethyl Vanillin, Beta-Ionone, Raspberry Ketone, Ethyl Hydroxypyrone, ◊Euterpe Oleracea (Acai) Fruit Oil, Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate, Laureth-21, Myristic Acid, ◊Avena Sativa (Oat) Kernel Flour, Cellulose, Arachidic Acid, Lauric Acid, ◊Oleic Acid, Disodium Phosphate, Polysorbate 60, Sodium Phosphate, Tocopherol, Sodium Dehydroacetate, Phenoxyethanol, Iron Oxides (CI 77499).

◊Naturally-Derived / D'origine Naturelle

ISO 16128: 80% Natural Origin Ingredients / 80% D'ingrédients d'origine naturelle.

What It’s Packaged In

Made with recycled plastic and a biodegradable wand, our Comeback Mascara is completely waste-free.

Full Size: Fill Size: 8 mL / 0.27 Fl. Oz.
Travel Size: Fill Size: 3.25 mL / 0.11 Fl. Oz.

Hand holding various crystals against a pink background

Ingredients

◊Water/Aqua, Acrylates/Ethylhexyl Acrylate Copolymer, Glyceryl Stearate, ◊Oryza Sativa (Rice) Bran Wax, ◊Glycerin, Tribehenin, Stearic Acid, Synthetic Wax, Palmitic Acid, Dimer Dilinoleyl Dimer Dilinoleate, ◊Jojoba Esters, ◊Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Wax, ◊Rhus Succedanea (Japanese) Fruit Wax, ◊Camellia Sinensis (Green Tea) Leaf Extract, Hydroxyethylcellulose, Caprylyl Glycol, ◊Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Oil, Sodium Hydroxide, Ethyl Vanillin, Beta-Ionone, Raspberry Ketone, Ethyl Hydroxypyrone, ◊Euterpe Oleracea (Acai) Fruit Oil, Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate, Laureth-21, Myristic Acid, ◊Avena Sativa (Oat) Kernel Flour, Cellulose, Arachidic Acid, Lauric Acid, ◊Oleic Acid, Disodium Phosphate, Polysorbate 60, Sodium Phosphate, Tocopherol, Sodium Dehydroacetate, Phenoxyethanol, Iron Oxides (CI 77499).

◊Naturally-Derived / D'origine Naturelle

ISO 16128: 80% Natural Origin Ingredients / 80% D'ingrédients d'origine naturelle.

Packaging

Made with recycled plastic and a biodegradable wand, our Comeback Mascara is completely waste-free.

Full Size: Fill Size: 8 mL / 0.27 Fl. Oz.
Travel Size: Fill Size: 3.25 mL / 0.11 Fl. Oz.

How to Recycle

Use up until you reach the bottom of the tube. Once you've gotten the most out of your mascara, clean thoroughly, then recycle through various recycling collectives.

OUR #NOBADVIBES BANNED LIST

We ban over 2700 ingredients from our formulas. It started with the 1300+ ingredients banned in the EU and every potential carcinogen, endocrine and hormone disruptor, allergen & irritant included in California Prop 65. And we don’t stop there - we ban any other ingredient with negative health concerns, potential environmental effects, and of course all animal-derived ingredients.

OUR #GOODVIBESONLY INGREDIENT CODE

ĀTHR Beauty is a clean and sustainable beauty brand. That means we vet each ingredient to ensure it's clean, non-toxic but also complies with our sustainability practices. We are committed to  using organic, fair-trade, non-GMO ingredients wherever possible and BAN over 2700 ingredients in our formulas.
We are 100% vegan and cruelty-free forever.

Our #GOODVIBESBEAUTY Ingredients We Use Instead

‘Clean’ means more than just ingredients. Clean beauty means a clean conscience! It means that from our non-toxic, vegan formulas, to our sustainable, ethically-sourced ingredients and our zero-waste, recyclable packaging, we are bringing only good into this world. All our ingredients are ethically & sustainably sourced, certified organic, and certified fair-trade wherever possible.

SHOP CONFIDENTLY

Shop with confidence knowing all ATHR products are intentionally made guided by our unwavering commitment to high-impact, high-vibrational beauty that is always clean, vegan, sustainable and absolutely cruelty-free.

  • 5 stars: 21 (68%)
  • 4 stars: 4 (13%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 3 (10%)
  • 1 star: 3 (10%)
Some of the reviews shown are from related products the merchant grouped with this one.
A
Ashlee S.
New Favorite

I was super impressed with The Comeback mascara. It has a unique wand and formula that fully fluffs and lengthens your lashes in just a few swipes. Builds nicely and if you're a fan of volume, I think you'll love this one. No issues so far with smudging or flaking. Isn't too "wet" of a mascara. My only note is that it does have a bit of fruity smell that lingers post-application (but nothing too intense). Overall, one of my new favorite mascaras.

L
Laura Andrews
I'll come back for COMEBACK!

I am adoring this mascara! It is my new everyday, go-to, work to evening, wearable, comfortable, but still dramatic mascara.
Friends: I am 41, have fairly good but thinning eyelashes, and very sensitive eyes and eye areas. If a mascara dries stiff, my eyes get itchy and irritated (I can't wear Lash Clash, for instance). In the past I've enjoyed Ilia's mascara and Merit's, to give you an idea of my personal preferences. THIS MASCARA coats perfectly with one coat, no clumping, not too wet, and I use a little metal comb to separate lashes further. For daytime I can stop there. It dries to a soft, conditioning finish that does NOT flake or change shape. It does not fall out or into my eyes. In the evening, if I want to add another coat for drama, it goes on perfectly without arguing with the original coat.

I'll be back for COMEBACK MASCARA! She's a dream!

H
Helen Brawley
Nice mascara for thickness

Really am linking the thickness/volume of my lashes when using this mascara. I'm thrilled that it washes off easily when removing my makeup. It lasts well when wearing it. The formula of the product is thicker so I'm not sure how it will hold up to my typical 3 months of use before I use a new tube since it's only been a week but overall I do like this product.

K
Katelyn
Pretty good

For a clean formula mascara, this is one of the best I’ve used, but it still doesn’t compare to my favorite mascara. It comes out very wet. The brush gets matted down and it gets all over the top of the tube. Overall, it worked pretty well for volume and length but I wish the brush was better at separating.

S
Sarah Warren
New go-to mascara

I have been using the same drugstore brand mascara for many years, but the Comeback mascara is truly my new favorite. My eyes and skin have become increasingly sensitive with age, and when I put this mascara on, my eyes are happier than they have been in a long time. I have gotten waterproof mascara for years because my eyes tend to water when I have seasonal allergies (which is often). Now I am pretty sure that my eyes have been reacting to the mascara I used to use as well. Wearing the Comeback mascara feels fantastic on my eyes as well as looking incredible. The length and volume my lashes get actually surprised me the first time I used this mascara! Feels great, looks fantastic, and even though there is a very slight scent to it, this mascara has yet to end up in streaks down my cheeks from allergy tears. Amazing. I love it!

M
Maegan McHugh
Love it!

I’m really enjoying this mascara, it’s a drier formula, so no gloppy mess when applying. It lifts and lengthens, I’ve experienced no clumping and no smudging. It removes easily with eye makeup remover or warm water and my cleanser.

H
H.
Great mascara

I tried this mascara found it to be very easy to apply, no flaking or smudging, it wasn’t too wet or too dry, and it did a great job at lengthening and good job at thickening while giving a naturally great eyelashes look. It did not irritate my eyes or cause them to tear up, which almost always happens with “clean” mascaras for some reason. No heavy fragrance, and the brush is wild! And probably the secret to its application.
You can see from the picture I just did a quick application with no lash separator brush or primer and my lashes turned out fabulous.

A
Ashaye
Pleasantly Surprised

I didnt think i would love this mascara as much as i do. I've been a die hard fan of another natural mascara brand for years, recently they had changed the packaging and formula and i wanted to find a new one. I think this may be the new ONE.

Its longwearing. Wore in the shower without it getting all over my face. Its not crunchy. The applicator is great, easy to apply to lower lashes. Packaging is easy to open and close.
It does come off with warm water as advertised, but it doesnt run all over your face if your face gets wet. You have to actually try to take it off.
It smells good.

C
Cara G.
Amazing mascara!

I love this mascara! It gives my lashes a ton of length & definition. It goes on smoothly & stays on all day with no flaking, but still washes off easily without makeup remover.

L
Lauren Mendez
Sensitive Eye Friendly and Bold Lashes

This is a great mascara for everyday use. I love that this mascara is bold, does not irritate my sensitive eyes and has not smeared under my eyes.

K
Kirsten L.
AMAZING length!

This mascara rocks! It adds so much length without looking gloopy or spidery. You can see the length difference in the pic! Also, I love the fact I can wash it off using warm water rather than having to use remover. A total winner!

A
Anonymous
Never

Never received

A
Ashley Aschliman
Clumpy from the get go

Clumpy from the get go. My lashes look shorter and clumpy with this mascara. I tried multiple methods and none improved it's performance.

C
Charity
Best mascara!!!!!! This makes my lashes defined

Best mascara!!!!!! This makes my lashes defined and also fluffy. Like they curl out at the ends - very feminine. It’s a nice moisture level too! Love love loooove

S
SG
Received from Allure—love it!!

Received this wonderful mascara in my Allure BeautyBox and I absolutely love it! It doesn’t clump, goes on smoothly and enhances my lashes beautifully! I’m going to buy it here as soon as I need it. I’ve tried so many mascaras and this one ticks all the boxes. Highly recommend!

M
Mama Mimi
Love it

Love it love this brand for years!

N
Niki
New favorite

Makes my lashes look super full and long

A
Anonymous
disappointed

I initially received this mascara in my IPSY bag and loved it so I bought the full sized one but the full sized one was not the same. I dont know if it’s manufactured differently but I felt like it was really hard to get enough mascara on the wand and it wasn’t giving me the lift the tester one did. Unfortunately I had to toss this.

K
Kristina Keegan
The full size that I got was completely dried up

The full size that I got was completely dried up.

A
Anonymous
So I got this mascara in my ipsy bag

So I got this mascara in my ipsy bag, and I loved it so much finally needed to order some more so I ordered two tubes and the first one I have ordered and I’ve been using has seemed a little bit dry. I have not opened the second one I’m hoping it’s better.

k
katiezimm
Best Mascara ever!

I got a mini of the comeback mascara in my ipsy original bag and it is AMAZING! the length and volume it gives you is insane, the mascara doesn’t bleed even after 8 hour wear. and when you’re ready to take your makeup off, it comes off with ease. no more scrubbing your face raw to get your mascara off. when i’m due for more mascara i will 100% be purchasing the full size.

N
Nicole k
5 star best mascara ever

I don't like a lot of time doing my makeup. But i discovered this gem. Oh my goodness. I love the brush. It's the best. I we been searching for this for years now. Haven't had anything like it for 20 years. The best for full long eyelashes and light.

A
Anonymous
Purchased for a 3rd time! I love this mascara and I tell everyone about it

Purchased for a 3rd time! I love this mascara and I tell everyone about it. It volumizes and doesn't flake. Highly recommend.

C
Carmen
It really is a comeback

I love this mascara it really is a comeback. It actually smells good which I’ve never said about a mascara and it works really well, very simple and very effective.

E
Elena
My absolute favorite go-to mascara

This is my absolute favorite go-to mascara. Doesn’t smudge, creates a ton of volume, lasts all day, and comes off wash without any damage to lashes. It’s also become my go-to gift for girlfriends because of how many compliments I get when I have it on.